Life Story
Duncan Campbell was born about 1780 in Perthshire, Scotland. His gravestone describes him as a native of Perthshire who emigrated in 1818 and died at Beckwith at the age of seventy-one.1 No reviewed record yet identifies his parents.
By 1807, Duncan was living in the Killin and Kenmore parish area of Perthshire. On 7 August 1807, the birth of his son John was registered in Killin Parish.2 The following day, Duncan Campbell and Catherine McNaughton gave in their names for proclamation of marriage banns. The banns were recorded in both Killin and Kenmore, with Catherine’s surname appearing in variant forms.3, 4
The Scottish part of Duncan’s life comes into sharper focus through the Breadalbane estate. Historian Michael E. Vance places him on the north side of Loch Tay before emigration, connected with Shenlarich farm near Lawers. Vance identifies Duncan, John Robertson, and John McDiarmid as men who helped gather signatures for a petition to the Prince Regent about conditions on the Breadalbane estate. The estate factor, John McGillewie, took a hard view of Duncan and called him “one of the worst characters in the country.” Estate arrears records summarized by Vance show Duncan and a relative, Donald Campbell, carrying substantial arrears connected with Shenlarich before Duncan left Scotland.5
In 1818, Duncan left Scotland for Upper Canada with his wife Catherine and children John, Elizabeth, and Jannet. The family sailed on the brig Curlew, which left Greenock on 21 July 1818 and arrived at Quebec and Montreal on 9 September 1818.6, 7, 8 A Beckwith Township settler list records Duncan Campbell, from Scotland, arriving on the Curlew and being located in September 1818 on the northeast half of Lot 11, Concession 4, Beckwith Township.9
Duncan’s first years in Beckwith appear to have been successful enough for him to make the transition from settler to freeholder. His original land was the northeast half of Lot 11, Concession 4, and Vance states that by 1822 he had completed his settlement duties and obtained freehold to his land grant.5 He also became part of the Presbyterian community in Beckwith and was among the original members of the township’s first Presbyterian congregation when it formed in 1822.5
Over the next three decades, Duncan acquired, sold, and rearranged land in Beckwith. In 1827, he bought the southwest half of Lot 11, Concession 10, from Dennis Gingley for £75.10 In 1840, he bought fifty acres in Lot 11, Concession 4, from Patrick Nowlan.11 In 1841/1842, he acquired the southwest half of Lot 15, Concession 6, from William Merritt, then sold that parcel to Rev. John Smith in 1844/1845.12, 14 He also bought a one-acre parcel in Franktown from Nicholas O’Neil in 1842, a parcel that appears again in his will in connection with his daughter Ann and grandson Duncan O’Neil.13
On 20 November 1849, Duncan made his will, describing himself as Duncan Campbell of Beckwith Township, yeoman, “weak in body but of perfect mind and memory.” He provided for his “dearly beloved wife” Catherine and named children John, Donald, Archibald, Isabella, Betsy, Catherine, Ann, and Margaret. He also named his grandson Duncan O’Neil, eldest son of his daughter Ann.15
The same day, Duncan conveyed about 300 acres in Beckwith to Archibald Campbell for £100. The will referred to a bond from Archibald connected with Catherine’s support, and together the two documents show Duncan settling his land and family obligations near the end of his life.16
Duncan probably died at Beckwith on 19 May 1850. The day and month come from the gravestone, but the year is resolved by the registered will memorial: Duncan’s executors executed the memorial on 13 June 1850, it was registered on 15 June 1850, and it describes him as “the late Duncan Campbell.”1, 15
Duncan Campbell’s records trace a life lived in two very different worlds. In Perthshire he was a tenant on the north side of Loch Tay, caught up in estate arrears, shifting tenancies, and organized petitioning against the Breadalbane estate. In Beckwith, he became an early Scottish settler, secured his land, joined the first Presbyterian congregation, and accumulated enough property to make detailed provision for his wife, children, and grandson. The arc of his life runs from a precarious tenancy in Scotland to an established place in a new Upper Canadian township.
Research Notes
Scottish Residence and Breadalbane Estate Records
The Scottish portion of Duncan’s life rests partly on parish records and partly on Michael E. Vance’s study of Scottish settlers in the Upper Ottawa Valley. Vance cites Breadalbane estate records in the National Records of Scotland, including GD112 material concerning arrears, petitioning, and correspondence by estate factor John McGillewie. Those underlying estate records should be reviewed directly before stronger claims are made about Duncan’s exact residence, tenancy, debts, or military service.5
Vance identifies Duncan as a former tenant farmer on the north side of Loch Tay and connects him with Shenlarich farm near Lawers. Vance also states that Duncan had served as an officer in the Perthshire militia.5 That military statement has not yet been independently verified. A search of Perth & Kinross militia indexes has not located him, and the relevant service may have been local militia or Fencible service rather than a readily indexed militia record.
Children and Passenger List Issues
The known 1818 Curlew passenger-list transcription names Duncan Campbell, wife Catherine, and three children: John, age ten; Elizabeth, age eight; and Jannet, age six.7 Duncan’s 1849 will names sons John, Donald, and Archibald and daughters Isabella, Betsy, Catherine, Ann, and Margaret.15
This leaves an unresolved question about the complete family group at the time of emigration. Later records for Archibald Campbell give him as born in Scotland about 1817, which would place him before the 1818 migration, yet he is not named in the known passenger-list transcription.17 The discrepancy may reflect an incomplete transcription, children travelling separately, errors in later census ages or birthplaces, or other recording problems. The passenger list alone should not be treated as the full list of Duncan and Catherine’s children.
Betsy in the will is likely the Elizabeth named on the passenger list, but that identification should be confirmed by additional records. Jannet, named in the 1818 passenger-list transcription, is not clearly identifiable in the will.
Daughter Ann Campbell and the O’Neil Family
Duncan’s will directly names his daughter Ann and gives her a life interest in a one-acre parcel in Franktown, with the property then to pass to her eldest son, Duncan O’Neil.15 This is strong evidence that Ann was connected to the O’Neil/Neil family.
On 8 March 1842, Nicholas O’Neil of Beckwith, cooper, sold Duncan Campbell a one-acre parcel described as part of Block 11 in the southwest half of Lot 12, Concession 3, Beckwith.13 This appears to be the same Franktown/Block 11 parcel Duncan later left to Ann for life. The deed does not state Nicholas O’Neil’s relationship to Duncan or Ann, so the relationship should be supported by the will, children’s marriage records, and later land-chain evidence rather than by this deed alone.
Land Dealings
Duncan Campbell’s land records are extensive enough to track separately from the main biography.
| Date | Transaction | Land | Amount | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| September 1818 / by 1822 | Settlement location / freehold | Northeast half of Lot 11, Concession 4, Beckwith, 100 acres | Free grant / patent | Original Beckwith settlement land. Duncan was located here in September 1818, and Vance states that by 1822 he had completed his settlement duties and obtained freehold.9, 5 |
| 4 October 1827 | Dennis Gingley to Duncan Campbell | Southwest half of Lot 11, Concession 10, Beckwith, 100 acres | £75 | Ordered sold in Duncan’s will.10 |
| 10 March 1840; registered 12 March 1840 | Patrick Nowlan to Duncan Campbell | Northwest half of southwest half of Lot 11, Concession 4, Beckwith, 50 acres | £50 | Added land near Duncan’s original Concession 4 holding.11 |
| 10 January 1841; memorial signed 17 January 1842; registered 6 December 1842 | William Merritt to Duncan Campbell | Southwest half of Lot 15, Concession 6, Beckwith, 100 acres | £10 | Later sold by Duncan to Rev. John Smith.12 |
| 8 March 1842 | Nicholas O’Neil to Duncan Campbell | Part of Block 11 / Franktown, one acre | £11 | Likely the parcel later left to daughter Ann for life, then to Duncan O’Neil.13 |
| 8 March 1844; memorial signed 8 January 1845; registered 11 January 1845 | Duncan Campbell to Rev. John Smith | Southwest half of Lot 15, Concession 6, Beckwith, 100 acres | £50 | Resale of the Merritt parcel.14 |
| 20 November 1849; registered 15 June 1850 | Duncan Campbell to Archibald Campbell | About 300 acres in Beckwith | £100 | Major estate-planning conveyance to Archibald, made the same day as Duncan’s will.16 |
Death Date
Duncan’s gravestone gives his death as 19 May and has been transcribed as 1851.1 The registered memorial of his will was executed by his named executors on 13 June 1850, registered on 15 June 1850, and describes him as “the late Duncan Campbell.”15 The legal record is closer to the event and should be given greater weight for the year. The most likely death date is therefore 19 May 1850, but the gravestone-year conflict should remain noted unless a clearer cemetery image, burial register, probate record, or deed-register index resolves it.
DNA Evidence
Autosomal DNA matches have been identified among descendants of several of Duncan and Catherine’s children, including lines through John, Ann, Archibald, and Donald. These matches support the reconstructed family group, but they are not used here to mark any relationship as DNA-confirmed. Any DNA-confirmed status would require citations and relationship paths meeting the relevant DNA confirmation standard.
Evidence Timeline
-
Birth in Perthshire
Duncan's gravestone describes him as a native of Perthshire and gives an age consistent with a birth about 1780.
-
Killin and Kenmore parish records
John Campbell's birth was registered in Killin, and marriage banns for Duncan and Catherine were recorded in Killin and Kenmore.
-
Breadalbane estate context
Vance connects Duncan with Shenlarich near Lawers and with petitioning and arrears on the Breadalbane estate; the underlying estate records still need direct review.
-
Curlew migration
Passenger-list and arrival evidence place Duncan, Catherine, and named children on the brig Curlew from Greenock to Quebec and Montreal.
-
Beckwith Township settlement
A settler list places Duncan on the northeast half of Lot 11, Concession 4, Beckwith Township.
-
Landholding and Presbyterian community
Published and deed evidence places Duncan as an established Beckwith settler, congregation member, and active landholder.
-
Will and estate planning
Duncan's will named his wife Catherine, children, and grandson Duncan O'Neil; a same-day deed conveyed substantial land to Archibald Campbell.
-
Likely death at Beckwith
The day and month come from the gravestone; the 1850 year is supported by the registered will memorial describing Duncan as late in June 1850.
Family Group Sheet
- Spouse / family connection
- Catherine McNaughton / McNaughtan Campbell, banns proclaimed in Killin and Kenmore parishes in August 1807
- Children and direct-line notes
-
- John Campbell
- Elizabeth / Betsy Campbell
- Jannet Campbell - named in the Curlew passenger-list transcription but not clearly identified in the will
- Donald Campbell
- Archibald Campbell - later census evidence suggests a Scottish birth before the 1818 migration
- Isabella Campbell
- Catherine Campbell
- Ann Campbell O'Neil - direct-line child
- Margaret Campbell
Places in Duncan Campbell's Life
Documentary Base
Sources
memorial
[1] Duncan Campbell gravestone and Find a Grave memorial
Contemporary record Back to first citationCitation: Find a Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/185141015/duncan-campbell : accessed 10 June 2026), memorial page for Duncan Campbell, Find a Grave Memorial ID 185141015, gravestone photograph and inscription, maintained by J. C. Clark, originally created by ValleyBoy13.
Access: Find a Grave, memorial page and gravestone photograph.
- Supports Duncan Campbell's approximate birth year, Perthshire nativity, emigration year, age at death, and death day/month.
- The gravestone has been transcribed with an 1851 death year, which conflicts with the registered will memorial showing Duncan was already dead in June 1850.
church-record
[2] John Campbell birth registration, Killin Parish, 1807
Strong support Back to first citationCitation: ScotlandsPeople, Old Parish Registers, births, Killin Parish, Perthshire, John Campbell, son of Duncan Campbell, 7 August 1807; OPR Births 361/20, p. 319 of 343, accessed 12 June 2023.
Access: ScotlandsPeople, Old Parish Registers.
- Supports Duncan Campbell's presence in the Killin parish area in 1807.
- Identifies John Campbell as a son of Duncan Campbell.
church-record
[3] Duncan Campbell and Catherine McNaughtan marriage banns, Killin Parish, 1807
Strong support Back to first citationCitation: ScotlandsPeople, Old Parish Registers, marriages, Killin Parish, Perthshire, Duncan Campbell and Kat McNaughtan, 8 August 1807; OPR Marriages 361/10, p. 324 of 345, accessed 12 June 2023.
Access: ScotlandsPeople, Old Parish Registers.
- Supports Duncan Campbell and Catherine McNaughton/McNaughtan giving in their names for proclamation of marriage banns in Killin Parish.
- Documents a surname spelling variant for Catherine.
church-record
[4] Duncan Campbell and Catherine MacNaughton marriage banns, Kenmore Parish, 1807
Strong support Back to first citationCitation: ScotlandsPeople, Old Parish Registers, marriages, Kenmore Parish, Perthshire, Duncan Campbell and Catherine MacNaughton, 1807; OPR Marriages 360, p. 403 of 432, accessed 12 June 2023.
Access: ScotlandsPeople, Old Parish Registers.
- Supports the parallel Kenmore Parish proclamation of marriage banns for Duncan Campbell and Catherine MacNaughton.
- Helps place the couple in the Killin/Kenmore/Breadalbane area of Perthshire.
published-work
[5] Michael E. Vance, Imperial Immigrants, Duncan Campbell and the Breadalbane settlers
Strong support Back to first citationCitation: Michael E. Vance, Imperial Immigrants: The Scottish Settlers in the Upper Ottawa Valley, 1815-1840 (Toronto: Dundurn, Kindle ed.), pp. 286-287.
Access: Published study; page references from Kindle edition as cited in the research notes.
- Supports Duncan Campbell's association with the north side of Loch Tay, Shenlarich farm near Lawers, Breadalbane estate arrears, petitioning, and the hostile statement by estate factor John McGillewie.
- Also supports Duncan's early Beckwith settlement context, completion of settlement duties by 1822, Presbyterian congregation membership, and the unverified statement that he had served as an officer in the Perthshire militia.
- Underlying Breadalbane estate records should be reviewed directly before making stronger claims about exact tenancy, arrears, or military service.
passenger-list
[6] Duncan Campbell family aboard the Curlew, immigration correspondence entry, 1818
Strong support Back to first citationCitation: "Canada, Immigration and Settlement Correspondence and Lists, 1817-1896," database with images, Ancestry.com, entry for Duncan Campbell family aboard the Curlew, 1818; citing The National Archives, London, England, War and Colonial Department and Colonial Office: Emigration Original Correspondence, class WO 384, piece 3, North America Offices; Settlers, 1818; accessed 7 June 2023.
Access: Ancestry.com database with images, citing The National Archives, London.
- Supports Duncan Campbell's 1818 emigration with his family aboard the Curlew.
- Should be correlated with the transcribed passenger list and other settlement records.
passenger-list
[7] Passenger list of the brig Curlew, Greenock to Quebec and Montreal, 1818
Strong support Back to first citationCitation: Colonial Office 384, vol. 3, pp. 60-63 (123-127), passenger list of the brig Curlew, Greenock to Quebec and Montreal, 1818; National Archives of Canada microfilm B-877; transcribed at TheShipsList, "Passenger List - Curlew, Greenock to Quebec 1818," archived by Internet Archive Wayback Machine, capture dated 23 April 2024, https://web.archive.org/web/20240423023152/http://www.theshipslist.com/ships/passengerlists/curlew1818.shtml; original website accessed 29 March 2023.
Access: TheShipsList transcription of Colonial Office/National Archives of Canada passenger-list material, archived by Internet Archive.
- Names Duncan Campbell, wife Catherine, and children John, Elizabeth, and Jannet in the 1818 Curlew passenger-list transcription.
- The known transcription does not resolve the full family group because later evidence places additional children in Duncan's family.
newspaper
[8] Arrival of the brig Curlew reported in the Montreal Gazette, 1818
Contemporary record Back to first citationCitation: "Montreal Gazette - Arrival of Brig Curlew," Montreal Gazette (Montreal, Quebec), 16 September 1818, p. 3; Newspapers.com, accessed 7 June 2023.
Access: Newspapers.com image of the Montreal Gazette notice.
- Supports the September 1818 arrival context for the brig Curlew at Quebec and Montreal.
- Used as arrival context rather than as a full passenger-list source.
settler-list
[9] Beckwith Township settler list entry for Duncan Campbell, 1818
Strong support Back to first citationCitation: "1816-1822 Settlers Beckwith Township, Lanark County, Ontario, Canada," transcript and table, RootsWeb/Granny's Genealogy Garden, entry for Duncan Campbell, Scotland, ship Curlew, September 1818, Concession 4, Lot 11NE; accessed from saved copy, originally at RootsWeb.
Access: Saved copy of RootsWeb/Granny's Genealogy Garden transcript.
- Supports Duncan Campbell's September 1818 location on the northeast half of Lot 11, Concession 4, Beckwith Township.
- This is a transcript/table source and should be replaced or supplemented if the original settler list is located.
land-record
[10] Dennis Gingley to Duncan Campbell, Beckwith land deed, 1827
Contemporary record Back to first citationCitation: Lanark County (Ontario), Registrar of Deeds (South), vol. A-C, memorial no. 345/347, bargain and sale from Dennis Gingley to Duncan Campbell, dated and registered 4 October 1827; "Lanark, Ontario, Canada records," images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSVG-K7DF-6?view=explore : accessed 10 June 2026), image 207 of 634; Image Group Number 008129923.
Access: FamilySearch images of Lanark County Registrar of Deeds records.
- Supports Duncan Campbell's purchase of the southwest half of Lot 11, Concession 10, Beckwith, from Dennis Gingley for £75.
- This parcel was later ordered sold under Duncan's will.
land-record
[11] Patrick Nowlan to Duncan Campbell, Beckwith land deed, 1840
Strong support Back to first citationCitation: Lanark County (Ontario), Registrar of Deeds (South), vol. F-G, folio 16, memorial no. 16, bargain and sale from Patrick Nowlan to Duncan Campbell, dated 10 March 1840, registered 12 March 1840; "Lanark, Ontario, Canada records," images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSV5-K8V7?view=explore : accessed 10 June 2026), image 14 of 500; Image Group Number 008130252.
Access: FamilySearch images of Lanark County Registrar of Deeds records.
- Supports Duncan Campbell's 1840 purchase of 50 acres described as the northwest half of the southwest half of Lot 11, Concession 4, Beckwith.
- Documents expansion or rearrangement of Duncan's land near his original Beckwith holding.
land-record
[12] William Merritt to Duncan Campbell, Beckwith land deed, 1842
Contemporary record Back to first citationCitation: Lanark County (Ontario), Registrar of Deeds (South), vol. F-G, folio 96, memorial no. 158, bargain and sale from William Merritt to Duncan Campbell, indenture dated 10 January 1841, memorial signed 17 January 1842, registered 6 December 1842; "Lanark, Ontario, Canada records," images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSV5-K82S?view=explore : accessed 10 June 2026), image 355 of 500; Image Group Number 008130252.
Access: FamilySearch images of Lanark County Registrar of Deeds records.
- Supports Duncan Campbell's acquisition of the southwest half of Lot 15, Concession 6, Beckwith, for £10.
- This parcel was later sold to Rev. John Smith.
land-record
[13] Nicholas O'Neil to Duncan Campbell, Franktown parcel deed, 1842
Strong support Back to first citationCitation: Lanark County (Ontario), Registrar of Deeds (South), memorial no. 51, bargain and sale from Nicholas O'Neil to Duncan Campbell, dated 8 March 1842; "Beckwith Township, Lanark, Ontario, Canada records," images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSLG-NS1M-9?view=explore : accessed 10 June 2026), image 48 of 272; Image Group Number 008200302.
Access: FamilySearch images of Beckwith Township, Lanark County Registrar of Deeds records.
- Supports Duncan Campbell's purchase of a one-acre parcel from Nicholas O'Neil, described as part of Block 11 in the southwest half of Lot 12, Concession 3, Beckwith.
- Likely relates to the Franktown parcel later left to daughter Ann for life and then to grandson Duncan O'Neil, but the deed itself does not state the family relationship.
land-record
[14] Duncan Campbell to Rev. John Smith, Beckwith land deed, 1845
Strong support Back to first citationCitation: Lanark County (Ontario), Registrar of Deeds (South), vol. H-I, folio 366, memorial no. 200, bargain and sale from Duncan Campbell to John Smith, indenture dated 8 March 1844, memorial signed 8 January 1845, registered 11 January 1845; "Lanark, Ontario, Canada records," images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSLG-N4XM?view=explore : accessed 10 June 2026), image 197 of 578; Image Group Number 008200296.
Access: FamilySearch images of Lanark County Registrar of Deeds records.
- Supports Duncan Campbell's sale of the southwest half of Lot 15, Concession 6, Beckwith, to Rev. John Smith for £50.
- Documents Duncan's continuing land transactions in the 1840s.
will
[15] Will memorial of Duncan Campbell of Beckwith Township, 1849/1850
Contemporary record Back to first citationCitation: Lanark County (Ontario), Registrar of Deeds (South), Liber F, Beckwith, folios 115-116, memorial no. 88, will memorial of Duncan Campbell of Beckwith Township, will dated 20 November 1849, memorial executed 13 June 1850, registered 15 June 1850; "Beckwith Township, Lanark, Ontario, Canada records," images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSLG-NSBF-Y?view=explore : accessed 10 June 2026), image 76 of 272; Image Group Number 008200302.
Access: FamilySearch images of Beckwith Township, Lanark County Registrar of Deeds records.
- Names Duncan Campbell of Beckwith Township, yeoman; his wife Catherine; children John, Donald, Archibald, Isabella, Betsy, Catherine, Ann, and Margaret; and grandson Duncan O'Neil.
- Supports Duncan's death before execution of the memorial on 13 June 1850 and conflicts with the gravestone-transcribed death year of 1851.
- Provides the strongest currently reviewed family-group evidence.
land-record
[16] Duncan Campbell to Archibald Campbell, estate-planning deed, 1849/1850
Contemporary record Back to first citationCitation: Lanark County (Ontario), Registrar of Deeds (South), Liber F, Beckwith, folios 117-118, memorial no. 89, indenture from Duncan Campbell to Archibald Campbell, dated 20 November 1849, memorial executed 13 June 1850, registered 15 June 1850; "Beckwith Township, Lanark, Ontario, Canada records," images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSLG-NSBK-C?view=explore : accessed 10 June 2026), image 77 of 272; Image Group Number 008200302.
Access: FamilySearch images of Beckwith Township, Lanark County Registrar of Deeds records.
- Documents Duncan Campbell's conveyance of about 300 acres in Beckwith to Archibald Campbell on the same date as his will.
- Together with the will, supports the interpretation that Duncan was settling property and support obligations near the end of his life.
census
[17] Archibald Campbell household, 1881 Canada census, Beckwith
Contemporary record Back to first citationCitation: "Canada, Census, 1881," database, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MVX6-16G : accessed 10 June 2026), entry for Arch Campbell and Sarah Campbell, Beckwith, Lanark South, Ontario, Canada; district 111, sub-district D, family 140, page 32, volume 9.
Access: FamilySearch database entry for the 1881 Canada census.
- Supports later evidence that Archibald Campbell was born in Scotland about 1817.
- Creates a tension with the known 1818 Curlew passenger-list transcription, where Archibald is not named among Duncan and Catherine's children.